Showing posts with label Icon Patrol Raiden. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Icon Patrol Raiden. Show all posts

24 Sept 2014

Review: Icon Patrol Raiden gear


I've written a few favourable words about the Icon Patrol Raiden gear in the past but have never done a proper review. However, I am now in a position to do so, having tested it in all extremes over the past year-and-a-half, including one test which no rider ever hopes to experience—how the gear stands up in a crash.

Yes, I was particularly pleased at that moment.

I purchased the Patrol Raiden suit in spring 2013 in preparation for my Alpine journey. I was coming from the BMW Rallye 3 jacket and City 2 trousers which are high quality items, but the jacket is only waterproof with the liner in place (uncomfortably warm on rainy summer days), and the trousers are not waterproof at all. The Patrol Raiden gear has waterproof shells—with a removable liner in the jacket if added warmth is required—which is optimal for keeping dry and cool(er) when riding on warm, wet days.

The Patrol Raiden jacket retails for £370 and the trousers £285 (including our 20% VAT) which puts it in line with mid-range gear in this country. Initial impressions are that the gear is constructed to a high standard with consistent stitching throughout and no loose threads or imprecise seams. Fabrics are substantial and the gear feels weighty and strong. In this respect it is on par with the much more expensive BMW gear.

The Patrol Raiden gear (along with the standard Patrol gear) appears to be inspired by the snowboarding industry both in style and in fit which is no bad thing in my opinion. It is all about unrestrictive, comfortable and casual style. For this reason it stands out as much from the ultra-conservative and functional crowd in tailored dark-coloured adventure touring gear as with the look-at-me crowd in squeak-when-you-walk, quasi futurist, cyberdog-style catsuit racing gear (unless you are a model specimen of human body shape perfection, this type of gear is a big, resounding no, regardless of your delusions of body self-image, thank you very much—just no).

Some bad news, however—where the Patrol Raiden gear falls short is in the protectors. Elbow, shoulder, knee and hip protectors are included but they are cheap and nasty at best—and just an empty pocket exists where the back protector should go (although I understand from late 2013 a non-accredited high density foam back protector has been included). To bring the gear up to a level of safety with which I was comfortable, I had to spend another £100 on CE Level 2 D3O protectors all round (including back protector). Shame on Icon for not including these as standard in the first place on their flagship 'adventure' gear.

The gear uses fabrics of varying textures from a coarse weave on impact areas to a finer weave on other panels. The white panels have a dye sublimated topographic pattern which works remarkably well at masking light staining from dust and road grime—some clever attention to detail. The colour scheme is bright and gets noticed—this may put off some buyers but I prefer to be as conspicuous as possible when I'm on the road.

I've had a chance to use the gear in sub-freezing temperatures with snow falling to near desert temperatures in the high 30s (°C, that is), as well as in some extreme rainstorms. It performs as advertised which means I have remained dry and as comfortable as possible throughout, with some minor exceptions as noted below.

Icon Patrol Raiden jacket


The jacket fits on the larger side, particularly with the liner removed. There are 12 rubber-sealed, zippered vents which enable a high level of airflow on warmer days—it goes without saying that all 12 need to be zipped closed when it rains or water will come in. At temperatures above 13°C I'm perfectly comfortable without the liner wearing just a t-shirt underneath. Below this, the liner is effective to -10°C from firsthand experience, although I suspect any colder would require some type of heated gear to maintain comfort.

In the wet, the sealed vent zips work effectively to keep out water, and the main zip is doubly secured with a magnetic flap running the length of the jacket. This flap is notable as I would never want to go back to poppers after the convenience of these magnets.

The jacket is equipped with a removable hood (handy for keeping dry after parking the bike on a rainy day) and pouch on the back which can take a third party 1.5-litre hydration pack. Neither of these items interfere or flap about at speeds tested up to 120mph on the German autobahn.

The arms have hook-and-loop straps to adjust the fit and help to keep the elbow pads in the correct positions. There are countless pockets throughout, including a specially sealed mobile phone pouch on the inside left breast. One of the pockets has a cloth attached to an elasticated cord for cleaning your visor, and another, peculiarly, has a St Christopher charm sewn in. A good omen is a good omen, after all.

As with any waterproofed gear, the fabric does require re-treatment from time to time to maintain water repellency. I found myself slightly damp on the arms after a particularly wet ride when the jacket was about a year old, but this was resolved using a commercial spray-on fabric waterproofer.

The jacket has a tail to keep your lower back well-covered when seated on the bike—I've not had any need to connect the jacket and trousers thanks to this feature.

Icon Patrol Raiden trousers


The trousers are not as form-fitting as most other motorcycle trousers—let's just say gents will not go sterile wearing them. They are considered over-trousers, but I have always worn them on their own. Hook-and-loop straps enable easy adjustments the waist, accompanied by standard belt loops. The trousers come with braces (aka suspenders) which attach at the back via a zipper—I prefer using a regular belt and leaving the braces at home.

A double-ended zip runs the length of each leg up to the waistband making it easy to air out your legs on hot days when stopped. The zips are doubly secured with magnetic flaps in the same way as the jacket. The bottoms of each leg have poppers to shorten the length to one of two levels, if necessary. The trousers come with two sets of removable stirrups to prevent them riding up your boots but I have had no need for these.

The knee protectors can be adjusted to one of three heights to ensure they are positioned correctly. There are two zip pockets at the front, two button-up cargo pockets on the knees and two on the back. I would recommend not putting anything pointed or oddly shaped items in the cargo pockets as these could cause injury in a crash.

The trousers do not restrict movement due to their relaxed fit which is helpful when riding off road. They have proven to be waterproof in all intensities of rain, apart from one torrential motorway journey in France, where they eventually allowed some dampness to come through to the undersides of my thighs due to persistent spray from the bike's tyres.

Crashworthiness


I had the misfortune of putting my Patrol Raiden gear through the ultimate test in the Czech Republic when I came off the bike at 45–50mph and slid to a stop on the tarmac. I won't go into detail about all the damage (you can read about it here) but will simply say I walked away from that crash with not so much as a cut or bruise despite bashing my knee quite hard on the tarmac. A bit of luck notwithstanding, the gear is up to task with one caveat... upgrading the rubbish stock protectors with some quality D3O protectors (available directly from Icon)—and once again, Icon, these should be standard!

Summary


Quality gear at a fair price—the whole suit coming in at around £750 including the D3O pads. The Patrol Raiden gear compares favourably in materials, workmanship and features to the BMW Rallye 3 suit which totals £1,000.

Care is straightforward—after removing the pads they can be chucked into the washing machine on the handwash cycle with some mild handwashing detergent. And once a year a waterproofing treatment is necessary.

For riders who are not bothered about the lairy colour schemes and who can appreciate the extra conspicuity this offers, this gear works as advertised from touring to off roading. It is something a little bit different from the usual sea of black in the gear isle of your favourite motorcycle shop.

A year-and-a-half on, with the exception of the recent crash damage, nothing is wearing unduly and all seams look as new as they did on day one—as expected from a quality product. Putting my money where my mouth is, I have been so pleased with this gear that I am replacing it like-for-like following the Czech incident.

The jacket is available in red, orange and grey, and the trousers are available in matching grey. Find out more at www.rideicon.com.



Do you have Patrol or Patrol Raiden gear? Let me know your thoughts in the comments below.

6 Jul 2013

The gear and how it held up


Mechanical:

  • BMW F800GS Trophy with OEM aluminium panniers and usual bits - new rear pads €66 at BMW Motorrad in Kaprun Austria (nearly ready for replacement at the start of the trip)
  • Heidenau K60 Scouts - about 50% tread at the start, now about 20% tread
  • various tools + tyre irons/spare tube - not used
  • DRC mini foot pump - not used
  • chain lube - used daily 1–2x
Electronics:

  • GoPro Hero3 - no issues (but battery life is horrible)
  • Nikon D7000 + 2 lenses, polarising filters and speedlight - no issues, excellent battery life (at 75% after 500 shots)
  • SPOT Connect - absolutely rubbish, see below
  • BMW Navigator IV GPS - no issues, but software really needs a 'navigate to route' function to join up on pre-programmed routes... currently the only option is to navigate to start of route so you are on your own to find your way to a point along the route
  • Sena Bluetooth SMH-5 intercom - no issues, see below
  • iPhone 5 - no issues, Booking Tonight app was immensely useful
  • iPad 2 with camera connection kit and compact bluetooth keyboard - no issues, although not really needed along with laptop
  • DIN to 3x USB adapter with device cables - no issues, only used once as devices charged each evening in hotels
  • Sanyo Eneloop AA batteries + USB charger - not used (see below re SPOT Connect)
  • MacBook Air (work laptop) - no issues
Misc:

  • bike documentation/insurance - required, but not used
  • passports - only used to re-enter UK
  • St Christopher talisman - clearly it worked, we got back in one piece!
  • European Health Insurance Card (EHIC) - required, but not used
  • bank/credit cards + driving licence
  • emergency map - not used
  • personal hygiene items + ear plugs
  • carrier bags - for dirty laundry, wet gloves etc
  • small gifts for friends/family
Me:

  • Icon Patrol waterproof jacket/trousers/gloves + Variant helmet and spare visor - see below
  • TCX X-Desert waterproof boots - no issues, dry feet all the way!
  • Caterpillar shatterproof safety sunglasses - no issues
  • CamelBak 1.5l hydration pack - apart from a plastic taste to the water for the first few days, this was much more used than I thought it would be, wouldn't travel without it now
  • spare non-waterproof gloves - no issues
  • t-shirts/vests, shorts, cargos, trainers, underwear, socks
Zev:

  • BMW Boulder 2 jacket with waterproof liner/City 2 trousers - no issues, whomever BMW commissions to make their gear does it well and it is up to the task
  • Hein Gericke gloves - no issues
  • Shark S500 helmet - no issues, although not a particularly quiet helmet
  • Icon Patrol waterproof boots - no issues
  • waterproof over-suit - cheap and nasty and performed as expected at its price point
  • shirts/vests, shorts, jeans, shoes, underwear, socks

+++ Sena SMH-5 Bluetooth headset/intercom


This was the quiet star of the show—from hot to cold, and rain to snow these little units never stopped, never gave any problem at all. They are the least expensive units in Sena's range but well-featured and support multiple bluetooth connections, so GPS instructions, mobile phone, music player and intercom functions all work as expected. Battery life is fantastic, with the intercom open all day they last nearly 2 days on a charge, and charge via USB. This is an example of a device that does what it should do without any fuss. Are you listening, SPOT?

Photo: Sena SMH5 • Source: Sena Technologies

+++ Icon Patrol Raiden gear + Variant helmet


Couldn't be more pleased, it's not particularly expensive gear compared to some but it is well constructed, fits me perfectly and works as advertised. I've shelled out a bit extra to replace the stock, unremarkable pads with D3O versions (CE Level 2) but otherwise it is as shipped. I stayed completely dry through all sorts of rain, with one exception—a bit of dampness seeping through the undersides of the trousers after 2 hours of downpour including an hour on the French motorway. The Variant helmet shape is also great in rain as the airflow combined with the peak keeps the visor clear of rain, and in hot weather it is the best ventilated helmet I've had to date. A lot of people seem to have an aversion to brighter coloured gear but to be blunt I don't and whatever makes people see me means one less person to plough into me on the road. Too bright for you? They make their gear in black also. And the hood is great when you take off the helmet on a rainy day. Doesn't flap at speed either.

--- SPOT Connect


The biggest disappointment of the trip with respect to gear—YES I know it says on their website that they recommend using special Energizer Lithium batteries but what they don't say is that other batteries either don't work at all, or only last an hour or so. The special Energizers are virtually impossible to find anywhere in Europe. Top that off with constant Bluetooth connectivity issues (phone and device stop talking) and a stupid app on the phone which needs to be in the foreground or the unit stops sending tracking points, and you have a product that would do better smashed at the bottom of a rocky Alpine chasm than come along on my next trip. Infuriatingly disappointing after wasting a shitload of cash on this plus another shitload of cash on the subscription fees. And the map sharing function on their website works like something from 1999. In 2013 devices should not be such a struggle—are you listening SPOT? Built-in battery, USB charging and up-to-date software should not be too much to ask for a 'premium' product.

Photo: SPOT Connect • Source: SPOT LLC


Alps 2013 quick links


Day 1: London to Lille
Day 2: Lille to Hagondange
Day 3: Slow road to Ammerschwihr
Day 4: Ammerschwihr
Day 5: Ammerschwihr to Thônes
Day 6: Thônes to.... Thônes
Day 7: Thônes to Ruèras
Day 8: Ruèras to Flachau
Day 9: Flachau
Day 10: Flachau to Wemding
Day 11: Wemding to Urberach
Day 12: Urberach to Antwerp
Day 13: Antwerp to London

The gear and how it held up
The trip in hindsight